Why Ontario's Poker Players Stand to Lose Big in a Global Pool

The Ontario government's recent proposal to reintegrate the province's online poker ecosystem into the global player pool has raised eyebrows and concerns among local players and industry experts alike. While the move is touted as a step towards greater competitiveness and broader engagement, a closer examination reveals numerous potential downsides that could undermine the thriving local poker community and be a detriment to the province's economy at large.

According to a recent report by CBC News, the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (AGCO) is considering allowing provincially licensed online gambling operators to combine their Ontario poker player pools with international counterparts. The AGCO suggests that this integration could enhance liquidity and offer more gaming options to players. However, this optimistic outlook fails to account for the unique advantages that the current isolated system provides to Ontario residents. Stakeholders make a dubious claim that the current framework drives players into the grey market, which in our view is simply not the case for the vast majority of players who prefer the safety of the local regulated market and it's softer player pool.

Source: CBC News - AGCO considers allowing Ontario online gambling operators to combine poker player pools with other jurisdictions

The Success Story of Ontario's Exclusive Poker Ecosystem

Since the establishment of Ontario's segregated online poker market, many local players have experienced unprecedented success and stability. The current framework ensures that all winnings remain within the provincial economy, fostering financial growth and providing a reliable income source for numerous Ontarians who previously struggled in the fiercely competitive global arena. This localized approach has proven to be very popular among Ontario players who were initially skeptical of the geo-fenced market.

As highlighted by industry insights from Pokerfuse, the closed market has created a more balanced playing field, allowing local grinders to flourish without the overwhelming pressure and competition characteristic of international pools. This environment has not only boosted individual incomes but has also contributed positively to the province's economic health by retaining funds and stimulating local spending.

Source: Pokerfuse - Keep It Closed: Not All Ontario Online Poker Players Want to Share Liquidity

The Looming Threats of Global Integration

Rejoining the global player pool poses significant risks that could reverse these gains and introduce a host of new challenges. The international online poker landscape is notoriously cutthroat, with a higher concentration of seasoned professionals and, alarmingly, a prevalence of unethical practices such as real-time assistance (RTA) and collusion which plague the global pool often as high-profile scandals that get exposed are just the tip of the iceberg.

These dishonest tactics are often associated with organized groups operating in regions where economic hardships and socio-political instability create incentives for illicit behavior. While it is crucial to acknowledge that not all players from these areas engage in such activities, the reality remains that integrating with a global pool increases exposure to these risks, thereby compromising the integrity and fairness of the game for Ontario players. These types of scandals haven't hit the Ontario market as of yet, and the only adjacent happening has been global players accused of accessing Ontario platforms using VPNs, further evidence that most of the risk lies abroad.

Impact on Ontario's Professional and Recreational Players

The proposed integration threatens to dismantle the supportive ecosystem that has empowered Ontario's professional poker community. Many local pros, who have built successful careers within the current system, may find themselves outmatched and unable to sustain their incomes amidst the intensified global competition. The potential loss of livelihood for these individuals is not just a personal setback but also a detriment to the province's economic diversity and resilience. Their success, which has been nurtured by a more predictable and localized environment, would be jeopardized by the influx of tougher competition and and rampant dishonesty in the global player pool.

Recreational players, who contribute significantly to the vibrancy and sustainability of the online poker scene, stand to suffer as well. The enjoyment and occasional successes that keep these players engaged are likely to diminish when faced with a steeper learning curve and the possibility of encountering unfair play. This could lead to decreased participation, reduced player retention, and ultimately, a shrinking local market that fails to support both casual and professional players alike. Rec players who typically have limited disposable income for gaming will see their funds not stretch as far, detracting from the gaming experience. As their experience deteriorates, we can expect a decline in participation.

A Short-Sighted Move That Could Harm the Ontario Government's Revenue

So far we explored the dangers that Ontario's poker players face if the province decides to reintegrate into the global online poker pool. The concerns for local professionals and recreational players are substantial, but the potential repercussions extend beyond the players themselves, threatening to undermine the broader economic and social fabric of Ontario.

One of the most glaring oversights in the Ontario government's push to rejoin the global pool is the potential for a significant decline in gaming-related revenue. While proponents of the plan argue that integrating with the global market will increase player activity and, by extension, tax revenues, this assumption is dangerously optimistic.

The reality is that Ontario's player base is likely to shrink as they face harsher competition from seasoned global professionals. Many recreational players—who currently make up a substantial portion of the province's online poker community—could be discouraged by frequent losses and the stark contrast in skill levels. As a result, these players may choose to reduce their participation or quit altogether, leading to a reduction in overall gaming activity.

Moreover, the funds that Ontario players do lose in this global environment are unlikely to stay within the province. Instead, they will flow to players in other parts of the world, particularly regions where the cost of living is lower, and the incentive to play is higher. This outflow of money represents a direct loss to Ontario's economy, draining resources that would otherwise be spent locally. While the current system not only supports the individual players but also circulates the money back within the Ontario economy. When winnings stay local, they contribute to the province's financial health, supporting businesses. Transitioning back to a global pool would mean that money lost by Ontario's recreational poker players will flow out to international jurisdictions.

The Global Pool: A Breeding Ground for Unfair Play

Another critical issue with rejoining the global player pool is the increased risk of exposure to unethical practices that have plagued the international online poker scene for years. As discussed, real-time assistance (RTA) tools and collusion among players, especially from economically disadvantaged regions, have become a persistent problem. While not every player from these areas engages in dishonest behavior, the prevalence of such practices is undeniably higher in regions where economic pressures are more intense.

For Ontario's players, this means a less enjoyable and potentially frustrating gaming experience. Recreational players, in particular, are at risk of being targeted by sophisticated rings of players who use these tactics to exploit inexperienced opponents. The result is a playing environment where fairness is compromised, and the enjoyment of the game is diminished.

Who Really Stands to Benefit?

Given the numerous downsides, it begs the question: who actually benefits from Ontario's re-entry into the global poker pool? The answer, unfortunately, points to a narrow set of interests that do not align with the broader well-being of Ontario's poker community or economy.

1. The Online Poker Sites

The primary beneficiaries of this move are the online poker operators themselves. By consolidating player pools, these companies can reduce their overhead costs associated with managing separate platforms for different regions. The global pool also makes it easier for these sites to hit guaranteed prize pool amounts and offer larger promotions, which can attract more players and increase their overall profitability.

However, this increased profitability comes at the expense of Ontario's players, whose chances of success diminish in the face of tougher global competition.

2. Global Professionals

Professional poker players from outside Ontario are also poised to benefit from this change. They gain access to a new pool of recreational players—many of whom are less skilled and more prone to making mistakes—that they can exploit for profit. This dynamic creates a predatory environment where Ontario's recreational players are at a distinct disadvantage, ultimately leading to a net outflow of funds from the province and we suspect the killing of the golden geese.

The Ontario Government's Gamble

The Ontario government's consideration of this policy shift appears to be a gamble with long odds. While the promise of greater player liquidity and larger prize pools may seem appealing on the surface, the underlying risks to Ontario's poker community and economy are substantial. The move threatens to dismantle the local success stories that have flourished under the current system, drive recreational players away from the game, and reduce the province's gaming revenue—all while benefiting a select few outside of Ontario.

As the province weighs its options, it is crucial to consider the broader implications of this decision. The current system, while not perfect, has fostered a thriving poker ecosystem that supports local players and contributes positively to Ontario's economy. Rejoining the global pool, on the other hand, risks sacrificing these gains for a speculative increase in activity that may never materialize. The Ontario government would be wise to keep its poker community intact and protect the economic interests of its citizens by rejecting this ill-conceived proposal.

When this matter is brought before the courts this fall, we hope that they do the right thing for Ontarian's and not bow to the pressure of the major industry players and what I suspect are Ford donors who stand to benefit at all of our expense.

For more information and ongoing coverage of this issue, stay tuned to OntarioPoker.ca.

‍